Commutation and remission — MCQs

25 min Score: 0 Attempted: 0/25

1. What is the primary difference between remission and commutation of sentences?
(A) Remission substitutes a lesser penalty, commutation reduces the sentence
(B) Commutation reduces the sentence partially, remission releases the offender fully
(C) Both are the same and can be used interchangeably
(D) Remission reduces a portion of the sentence, commutation substitutes a lesser penalty

2. In remission, the offender:
(A) Is released from custody entirely
(B) Is pardoned
(C) Receives a non-custodial sentence automatically
(D) Serves a reduced sentence but remains under custody or supervision

3. In commutation, the offender:
(A) Is released from custody or has the sentence reduced to a non-custodial one
(B) Serves the original sentence in full
(C) Must serve additional punishment
(D) Is fined instead of imprisoned

4. Which constitutional provision gives the President of India the power to remit or commute sentences?
(A) Article 72
(B) Article 53
(C) Article 161
(D) Article 14

5. Who can exercise the power to remit sentences at the state level?
(A) The Governor of the State under Article 161
(B) The Chief Justice
(C) The President
(D) The Parliament

6. Under the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973, which section deals with suspension or remission of sentences?
(A) Section 432
(B) Section 16A
(C) Section 431
(D) Section 5

7. Who can grant remission or suspension of a sentence according to the Code of Criminal Procedure?
(A) Only the judiciary
(B) Only the police
(C) Only the appropriate government (Central or State)
(D) Any prison officer

8. On what grounds can an executive order of remission be challenged in court?
(A) All of the above
(B) Order is mala fide
(C) Order based on extraneous or irrelevant considerations
(D) Order passed without application of mind

9. What is one of the purposes of granting remission or commutation?
(A) Increase the severity of punishment
(B) Deny rehabilitation opportunities
(C) Punish the offender for prior offences again
(D) Lighten the burden of punishment on offenders showing good behavior

10. What concern arises regarding victims when offenders are granted remission?
(A) There is no impact on victims
(B) Victims automatically forgive the offender
(C) Victims receive financial compensation
(D) Victims may feel justice has not been served

11. Which case emphasized that reasons must be indicated while exercising remission powers under Articles 72/161?
(A) Veen v The Queen [No 2]
(B) Epuru Sudhakar & Another v. Govt. of A.P. & Ors.
(C) Mabo v Queensland
(D) Donoghue v Stevenson

12. What are some factors that can invalidate an executive remission order?
(A) Arbitrary decision
(B) Ignoring relevant materials
(C) Exercising power mala fide
(D) All of the above

13. Which law allows an offender to apply for remission through an officer of the jail?
(A) Article 161 of the Constitution
(B) Sentencing Act
(C) Section 432(5) of the Code of Criminal Procedure
(D) Army Act

14. What is a secondary purpose of punishment that remission or commutation takes into account?
(A) Increasing imprisonment duration unnecessarily
(B) Avoiding rehabilitation
(C) Ignoring societal norms
(D) Ensuring the offender reflects on their crimes and realizes guilt

15. Why might remission or commutation also help the prison system?
(A) Increase the prison population
(B) Punish prisoners more harshly
(C) Reduce the strength of prisoners to allow space for new convicts
(D) Prevent parole

16. What is the primary purpose of remission and commutation of sentences?
(A) To increase the severity of punishment
(B) To reduce the length or severity of a sentence for good behavior, rehabilitation, or other mitigating circumstances
(C) To punish the offender more severely than the court intended
(D) To replace imprisonment with corporal punishment

17. In remission, the offender:
(A) Is released entirely from custody
(B) Automatically receives a fine instead of imprisonment
(C) Serves a reduced sentence but remains under custody or supervision
(D) Is pardoned

18. In commutation, the offender:
(A) Serves the original sentence in full
(B) Has their sentence substituted with a lesser penalty and may be released from custody
(C) Must serve an extended sentence
(D) Receives a non-custodial fine only

19. Under which constitutional article can the President of India grant remission, commutation, or pardon?
(A) Article 53
(B) Article 72
(C) Article 161
(D) Article 14

20. Who can grant remission at the state level?
(A) The President
(B) The Supreme Court
(C) The Governor under Article 161
(D) The Chief Minister

21. Which section of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973, provides for the suspension or remission of sentences?
(A) Section 431
(B) Section 16A
(C) Section 432
(D) Section 5

22. Who decides whether a remission application should be granted under Section 432?
(A) The court alone
(B) The executive (appropriate government) at its discretion
(C) The prison officer only
(D) The Parliament

23. On what grounds can an executive remission order be challenged in court?
(A) All of the above
(B) Order is mala fide
(C) Order based on extraneous or irrelevant considerations
(D) Order passed without application of mind

24. What is one of the practical purposes of remission in the prison system?
(A) To punish prisoners more severely
(B) To bypass rehabilitation programs
(C) To reduce the prison population and make space for new convicts
(D) To increase the severity of sentences for other offenders

25. What is a potential concern of granting remission or commutation regarding victims and society?
(A) It always increases trust in the legal system
(B) It ensures victims are compensated financially
(C) It has no impact on public perception of justice
(D) Victims and society may perceive it as unfair if offenders are released early